Showing posts with label United Kingdom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label United Kingdom. Show all posts

Friday, July 25, 2008

An orgy yes, but no Nazi theme.

This is a pretty straightforward case, but the facts are memorable, to say the least. In March of 2008, the British tabloid News of the World reported that Max Rufus Mosley, the London-born president of the Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile, had hired five prostitutes to act out a Nazi prison camp fantasy. Mosley does not dispute that he had hired the ladies to help him act out certain fantasies - the report indicates that "the court was played covertly recorded videos that showed Mosley being bound and whipped, then relaxing naked with a cup of tea." The part that Mosley denied, however was the "Nazi" aspect:

Mosley told the court he had an interest in sadomasochism going back 45 years, but said he found the idea of Nazi sex fantasies abhorrent. He said he and the women acted out a German prison scenario, with no Nazi overtones.


Really, there's not much more that can (or must) be said with respect to the facts. Judge for yourself:



So why the blog? Because Mosley sued the News of the World, for invasion of privacy, and in part for falsely claiming that there was a Nazi angle to his, ahem, hobby. And, with a speed that would spin heads in an American court, the UK tribunal completed a trial and came down with a decision awarding Mosley $120,000 in damages and legal costs of about $1.7 million.

In the U.S., aspects of this case may well have turned out differently, as Mosley's prominent position in a popular sport would have made him a public figure, held to a higher standard for a defamation cause of action. Put up against an "actual malice" standard, it would be hard to say that the tabloid had acted with reckless disregard for the truth in using "Nazi" to describe a German prison scenario in which one participant wore a Luftwaffe jacket. Seriously, how big a leap must one make to get there from an abusive "German prison" fantasy? Does that not, by itself, bring Nazism to mind? In Mosley's defense, utterly bizarre as it is, at least the role-playing prostitutes suggest that he is in prison for committing an actual crime, rather than for his ethnic origin.

A final note - although U.S. law on the subject varies widely from state to state, many jurisdictions pose harsh penalties for surreptitious audiotaping. In Florida at least, the defendants would have been subject to a fairly stiff penalty - although not stiffer than the penalty faced by Mosley for being such a naughty prisoner!